News Flash
  • Vacancies reported by the field formations.click here
  • Corrigendum to Office Order No.10/2017 dated 12.09.2017 - promotion to the post of Chemical Examiner, Gr.II - reg. click here
  • Order extending date for filing of TRAN-1 under Rule 117 has been issued. click here
  • Minutes of the राजस्वज्ञानसंगम-Annual Conference of Tax Administrators, 2017 held at New Delhi on 01-02 September, 2017 have been uploaded on ANTARANG
  • Constitution of National Anti-profiteering Authority(NAA) under GST. click here
  • The Opt-In for Composition Levy for 2017-18 is available on GST portal. The window for opting in for composition levy for 2017-18 will be open till 30th Sep midnight. It will be applicable from 1st Oct 2017. Registration of TDS service will be available on GST portal shortly.
  • CGST Rules, 2017 as amended upto 18/09/2017 For details click here
  • Instruction for filing of Special Leave Petition against Orders of Hon’ble High Courts staying Collection of Tax under GST. click here
  • Filling up the post of Deputy Director in Financial Intelligence Unit, India (FIU-IND), Delhi under Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue on deputation basis.click here
  • Two notifications granting exemption from registration to job workers and suppliers of handicraft goods in specified cases.click here
  • GeM- Training schedule and PPT for HoD's.click here
  • Promotion/ Transfer/ Posting order in r/o Group 'A' Officers of CRCL under CBEC.click here
  • Transfer Policy in r/o Group 'A' Officers of CRCL under CBEC.click here
  • Notifications extending filing of GSTR-1, GSTR-2, GSTR-3 and GSTR-6 have been issued.click here
  • Suggestions to be send for Draft Expenditure Budget Manual, 2017 either through mail or fax latest by 15.09.2017-click here
  • Decisions of the GST Council on Services taken in the 21st GST Council Meeting held on 9 Sept 2017. -click here
  • List of goods where changes in GST rates have been recommended by the GST Council and increase in Compensation Cess rates of motor vehicles For details click here
  • Weekly newsletter from Chairman, CBEC to all officers and staff of CBEC-click here
  • Filing of GST return click here
  • Data regarding transfer of AIOs in the Zone- to be shared by 8th Sep 2017. click here
  • "Extension of due dates for furnishing details/Returns for the months of July, 2017 and August, 2017" - click here
  • Suggestions to be send for Draft Expenditure Budget Manual, 2017.- click here
  • "CGST Rules, 2017 as amended upto 30/08/2017 have been uploaded".- click here
  • Circular on System based reconciliation of information furnished in FORM GSTR-1 and FORM GSTR-2 with FORM GSTR-3B has been issued.-click here
  • Notification waving late fee for July, 2017 return has been issued
  • "Notification issued for further amendment of CGST Rules".-click here
  • Important information for field formations regarding LAN infrastructure and WAN Connectivity - click here
  • Draft Customs Brokers Licensing Regulations, (CBLR) 2017 has been uploaded. For details - click here
  • Observance of Rashtriya Ekta Diwas (National Unity Day ) on 31st Oct, 2017. click here
  • Charter of Functions of DGGST For Details click here
View all

Section 37B Order No .1/1/2002-ST

F.NO. 177/5/2001 - CX4
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Excise and Customs

26th February, 2002

37B Order No .1/1/2002-ST

Sub.: Providing service of third party inspection and certification whether liable to Service Tax - regarding

In exercise of the power conferred under Section 37B of the Central Excise Act, 1944 (as made applicable to Service Tax by Section 83 of the Finance Act,1994), the Central Board of Excise and Custom considers it necessary, for the purpose of uniformity in connection with classification of services, to issue the following instructions.

2.      Doubts have been raised as to whether " third party inspections and certifications" carried out by certifying agencies in respect of marine as well as non-marine equipments, can be considered as a service provided by a "consulting engineer" or not.

3.      This matter was also raised by two service providers before the Mumbai High Court, in Writ Petition No 1436/2000. The petition was disposed of by the Hon'ble Court on 11.9.2001 with directions to the Board to issue a Section 37B Order in the matter for ensuring uniformity.

4.      The two service providers were heard in the matter on 4th January, 2002. Views of the field formations were also procured. Some of the types of inspection and certification work carried out by the said two service providers relate to :-

1. MARINE
(i) New Construction
(ii) Periodical Surveys
(iii) Marine equipment and components
(iv) Type approval
(v) Marine specification
(vi) Confirmation of class
2. NON-MARINE
(i) Plan approval and Inspection
(ii) ASME Inspection Service
(iii) System Integrity and Management

5.      It is observed that as per clause (18) of Section 65 of the Finance Act,1994, "Consulting Engineer" means any professionally qualified engineer or an engineering firm who, either directly or indirectly, renders any advice, consultancy or technical assistance in any manner to a client in one or more disciplines of engineering".

6.      The issue, therefore, is whether the service of 'third party inspection and certification' carried out by a professionally qualified engineer or an engineering firm can fall under the category of advice, consultancy or technical assistance.

7.      The main point raised by some service providers is that where they are carrying out any certification as required by any statute it cannot come under the purview of either consultancy, advice or technical assistance. As for example, some of them have been authorized u/s.9 of the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958, to survey and classify ships and issue necessary certification. [refer S.O.No.769(E) dt.7.11.97 issued under section 9 of the Act ibid].

8.      In the case of 'Management Consultants', the Board had clarified, in Para 11 of the sec.37B Order No. 1/1/2001 - ST dt.27.6.2001, that "..........banks who are required to play only a statutory role under any Act or regulation, such as Takeover Regulations of SEBI, and do not provide any advice or consultancy but merely verify and submit a report to the concerned authorities, in connection with merger and acquisition transaction, are not treated as Management Consultants..........". The definition of "Management Consultant" also uses the words 'consultancy, advice or technical assistance'.

9.      Certificates given under authority of any statute/international protocol/code/convention, cannot be considered to be a consultancy job. It is then to be examined whether this activity can come under the purview of advice or technical assistance. An advice is generally understood to be optional in nature and has no statutory force. It is upto the client to accept the advice or not. The activity of certification will therefore not fall under the category of advice. As regards 'technical assistance', it is observed that an assistance is normally for the purpose of achieving a particular aim or result. A certificate given by, say, the Boiler Inspector under the Factory's Act, 1948, about the safety of a boiler, cannot be considered to be an 'assistance' to the person using the said boiler in his factory. Thus, if a certifying agency issues a 'Cargo ship safety construction certificate' u/s.299A(i) of the Indian Merchant Shipping Act,1958, it cannot be considered to be either an advice or a technical assistance.

10.      To issue certificates under the authority of any statute it will obviously be necessary for the certifying agency to conduct some survey/inspection. Thus the survey/inspection by an agency for the purposes of issuing certificates by the same agency under an authority of law, will also not amount to consultancy, advice or technical assistance. If, however, the shipping company gets the ship surveyed or inspected by another, agency before taking it for certification by an authorized agency, only then can it be said that the first agency is providing some technical assistance or advice.

11.      It will, therefore, be essential to examine each activity of a service provider on the basis of facts, the terms of agreement between the assessee and the clients and the corresponding provisions of Indian or International Statute/Convention/Protocol or Code, to determine whether the certificate being given is under the authority of any such statute, convention, protocol or code. If it is so, the payment received for that service will not be taxable under the head " consulting engineer".

12.      Any other inspection, survey, assessment, technical assistance, consultancy, recommendation, advice, undertaken/provided directly or indirectly, by the assessee would be liable to Service Tax under the head 'Consulting Engineer'.

13.      Suitable Trade Notice may be issued for the information of the trade.

14.      Hindi version will follow.

15.      The receipt of this order may kindly be acknowledged.

Suraksha Katiyar
Under Secretary